Three Classes of Evidence
It
has been a cherished desire for a long time
to publish in serial form the life of Thakur from his childhood. After completing
the Kathamrita in six or seven volumes, material would be available to write
his life story as he recounted it himself. In this regard three classes of evidence
will be available.
First: Direct and recorded on the same day. This is what Thakur Sri Ramakrishna
said about his childhood, his states of sadhana (spiritual practices) etc. and
what the bhaktas recorded on the same day. The account of Thakur's life that
came directly from his holy lips and was published in the Sri Sri Ramakrishna
Kathamrita belongs to this class of evidence. The day M. saw Thakur's acts,
or heard from his holy lips, he recalled it and recorded in his daily dairy
that very day during the night (or in day time). This kind of rendering is obtained
by direct seeing and hearing - along with the year, the date, the day of the
week and the lunar date.
Second: Direct but unrecorded at the time of the Master. This is what the devotees
themselves heard from the holy lips of Thakur, they are recalling it and speaking
out now. This kind of version is also very good. The record of the other avataras
is generally of this kind. Even then twenty four years have passed. Herein there
is a greater possibility of mistakes than what is recorded immediately.
Third: Hearsay and unrecorded at the time of the Master. What one hears about
Thakur's childhood, or his states of sadhana
from his contemporaries like Hridya Mukherji, Roy Chatterji and other bhaktas
, or what one hears about the life of Thakur from the residents of Kamarpukur,
Jairambati, Shyam Bazaar, or from the circle of Thakur's bhaktas belongs to
the third class evidence.
At the time of writing Sri Sri Ramakrishna Kathamrita, M. relied upon the first
class evidence. If M. publishes Thakur's life in a serial form, for that, too,
he will rely mainly on the first class evidence. In other words, its contents
will rely on words which issued from Thakur's own lips.
Calcutta, 1317 B.Y., 1910 A.D.